<%@LANGUAGE="VBSCRIPT" CODEPAGE="1252"%> Monthly Bulletin








           SO2 EA and NOx EA
           December 2004
December 2004 SO2 EA and NOx EA MPI HEADLINES
SO2 EA MPI Up 1.90% - Vintage 2004 NOx EA MPI Down 0.30%

What are the Cantor Environmental Brokerage SO2 EA and NOx EA MPIs?
 
The Cantor Environmental Brokerage Market Price Indices (MPIs) are prices that reflect current market conditions for Clean Air Act Title IV SO2, and Section 126/NOx SIP Call emission allowances (EAs). The MPI is an average of the following three numbers (where available) (Note: fees and commissions are not.

RECENT TRANSACTION PRICE
Prices from the most recent transactions (sales, swaps, and options) either executed by Cantor Environmental Brokerage and/or reasonably believed by Cantor Environmental Brokerage to have occurred. Also note that the MPI does not include transactions that are reported as retirements or facility changes of ownership because such transactions may not be reflective of current market conditions.

  Lowest Offer Price
Lowest price, reported to Cantor Environmental Brokerage, at which a seller is willing to sell.

Highest Bid Price
Highest price, reported to Cantor Environmental Brokerage, at which a buyer is willing to buy.

If you would like to receive this bulletin as an e-mail attachment in Adobe format please fax this to 203-662-3643 with your e-mail address listed below, or send an email to apaton@cantor.com.  
For More Information Call (203) 662-3638
19 Old Kings Highway South, Darien, Connecticut 06820
Fax (203) 662-3643

www.emissionstrading.com

Note: All information contained here is obtained by Cantor Environmental Brokerage from sources believed to be accurate and reliable. However, because of the possibility of human and mechanical errors, as well as other factors, such information is provided "as is" without warranty of any kind and Cantor Environmental Brokerage, in particular, makes no representation or warranty as to the accuracy, timeliness, or completeness of this information. Under no circumstance shall Cantor Environmental Brokerage have any liability to any person or entity for (a) any loss or damage in whole or in part caused by, resulting from, or relating to any error (negligent or otherwise) or other circumstance involved in procuring, collecting, compiling interpreting, analyzing, editing, transcribing, transmitting, communicating, or delivering any such information, or (b) any direct, indirect, special, consequential, or incidental damages whatsoever even if Cantor Environmental Brokerage is advised in advance of the possibility of such damages, resulting from the use of, or inability to use, any such information. The data and information contained herein are, and must be construed solely as statements of opinions and not statements of fact or recommendations to purchase, sell, or hold SO2 or NOx EAs. All prices are merely indications of interest, do not represent firm bids and offers, and their terms are subject to change without notice. NOWARRANTY, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, AS TO THE ACCURACY, TIMELINESS, COMPLETENESS, MERCHANTABILITY, OR FITNESS FOR ANY PARTICULAR PURPOSE OF ANY SUCH DATA OR INFORMATION OROTHER OPINION IS GIVEN OR MADE BY CANTOR ENVIRONMENTAL BROKERAGE IN ANY FORM OR MANNER.

For information on trading SCAQMD RTCs and/or ERCs, SJVAPCD and BAAQMD ERCs, Illinois ATUs, ERCs, DERs, or Sewerage Facilities Charge Credits please visit or call 1-800-228-2955 ext. 1, 2, 4, 6, 7, 8, or 9. For information on trading HGA NOx Allowances, call 800-228-2955 ext. 13 or 14. For information on trading NOx Section 126/NOx SIP Call Allowances, and SO2 Allowances call (203) 662-3638 or 800-228-2955 ext. 6 or 12. For information regarding Greenhouse Gas Credits visit , or call 800-228-2955 ext. 10.



            December 2004
           CANTOR ENVIRONMENTAL BROKERAGE
           SO2 EA Market Price Index

Cantor Environmental BROKERAGE Market Price Index: $706.43

(Call 203-662-3638 for description)

  Bids* Offers* Trades MPI
Price/Volume 2,500 @ $700.00 2,500 @ $715.00 Not Listed  
Weighted Average $700.00 $715.00 $704.30 $706.43

 Immediate Settlement
    Best Prices ($/Allowance) Maximum Volume
Term Vintage Bid to Buy Offer to Sell Bid Offered
 1 Year Term  2004  $700.00  $715.00  2,500  2,500  Allowances
   2005  $697.27    2,500    Allowances
   2006  $695.45    2,500    Allowances
   2007  $684.25    2,500    Allowances
   2008  $649.25    2,500    Allowances

 Swaps
 
 
Swap Rates against vintage 2004 allowances
  2005 2006 2007 2008  
 Offer 0.39% 0.65% 2.25% 6.75%
Ratios for base years other than 2004 are available upon request.

  SO2 EA Market Beat

  The Cantor Environmental Brokerage SO2 EA
  Market Price Index increased by 1.90% this
  month from $698.23 in November 2004
  to $706.43 in December 2004.

 
 

            December 2004
           CANTOR ENVIRONMENTAL BROKERAGE
           NOx EA Market Price Index

BEST BIDS TO BUY   BEST OFFERS
2004 50 tons     $2,250/ton   2004 50 tons    $2,375/ton
2005 50 tons     $3,550/ton   2005 50 tons    $3,625/ton
2006 50 tons     $3,200/ton   2006 50 tons    $3,325/ton

 RECENT TRADE PRICES
 November 30, 2004 - December 23, 2004
V03-V04 for $2,240/ton V05 for $3,450/ton      
V05-V07 for $3,010/ton V06 for $3,250/ton      
V05 for $3,525/ton V06 for $3,225/ton      
V05 for $3,500/ton V05 for $3,550/ton      
V05 for $3,475/ton V05 for $3,575/ton      
V04for $2,175/ton V05 for $3,600/ton      
V04 for $2,225/ton V06 for $3,300/ton      
V05 for $3,425/ton V04 for $2,275/ton      
V05 for $3,375/ton V05 for $3,625/ton      
V05 for $3,425/ton V04 for $2,325/ton      
V05 for $3,375/ton V04 for $2,325/ton      
V05 for $3,375/ton        
V05 for $3,400/ton        
V04 for $2,200/ton        
V05 for $3,450/ton        

MARKET INDEX PRICE
   2004  $2,296/ton
  $7  339 tons trade this month  
   2005  $3,581/ton
  $7  900 tons trade this month  
 2006  $3,282/ton
  $18  350 tons trade this month  
   2007  N/A N/A   N/A  N/A  
 
 

            December 2004
           CANTOR ENVIRONMENTAL BROKERAGE
           Market News

EPA Releases Preliminary NOx Data

Late on December 3, 2004, EPA released preliminary emissions data for the 2004 ozone season. Actual emissions were approximately 471,000 tons, against an allocation of approximately 675,000 tons. We thus anticipate approximately 204,000 tons to carryover into 2005. The 2005 allocation is presently planned to be approximately 516,000 tons. With these figures in mind, there will be progressive flow control (Flow Control) next year.
 
The preliminary data suggests the following Flow Control ratio to be applied in 2005 to only 2003 and 2004 tons used (NOT banked) in 2005:
(10% x 2005 Allocation)
÷ Leftover 2003 & 2004 tons
= (0.10 x 516,000)
÷ 204,000
= 0.25

Please note that as the data is preliminary, this number is presently an indication, and not firm.

The number is remarkably close to the “guesstimates” that the market
 
established with the second quarter emissions data this past July. Tons sitting in accounts are NOT discounted. Only v03 and v04 tons used for 2005 compliance would be discounted (if at all). Using the 0.25 preliminary Flow Control number, 25 of every 100 tons would be useable on a 1 for 1 basis, with the 75-ton balance useable on a 2:1 basis. Thus, as a preliminary indication, every 100 tons of 2003 and 2004 used for compliance would equate with 63 vintage 2005 tons. Unused tons would not be discounted, and could be carried over for use or sale in the future.


SO2 Up Slightly Overall, But Off on Lackluster Month

As we head toward the end of the annual SO2 season, activity this past month was quite light. Trades that did occur had average prices slightly above last month’s trends, but ultimately finished below the $735 all-time-high price of last month. SO2 reconciliation must be complete by February 28, 2005, so we anticipate increased activity during January and February, as market participants arrive at their final long or short positions.


Thank You for Your Business and Have a Safe, Happy and Healthy Holiday Season and 2005!


For more information please call us at 800-228-2955.

 
 To Reach Cantor Environmental Brokerage Staff
 Call 800-228-2955 or Dial Direct:
 Andy Kruger
 Darien, CT
 ERCs/NOx & SO2 EAs/DERs
 800-228-2955 ext 6
 Lauren Kisling
 New York
 ERCs/NOx & SO2 EAs/DERs
 800-228-2955 ext 7
 Craig Poler
 Darien, CT
 ERCs/NOx & SO2 EAs/DERs
 800-228-2955 ext 3
 Ann Chernow
 New York
 Back Office
 800-228-2955 ext 7
 Laurie Gage
 New York
 ERCs/NOx & SO2 EAs/DERs
 800-228-2955 ext 7
 Christine Grandstaff
 Los Angeles
 RTCs/ERCs/DERs
 800-228-2955 ext 4
 Mike Hammond
 San Francisco
 RTCs/ERCs/DERs
 800-228-2955 ext 9
 Diarmuid McGarry
 San Francisco
 Back Office Manager
 800-228-2955 ext 3
 Josh Margolis
 San Francisco
 RTCs/ERCs/DERs
 800-228-2955 ext 1
 Bill Ross
 New York/San Francisco
 RECs
 800-228-2955 ext 7
 
Cantor Environmental Brokerage
19 Old Kings Highway South, Darien, Connecticut 06820
Tel. (203) 662-3638 Fax (203) 662-3643
www.emissiontrading.com